Dead Poets Society Scene Analysis Essays

Summary

Charlie wakes Todd in his bed and tells him that Neil is dead. Pitts, Meeks, and Knox are at the door. The next snowy morning, Todd heads down to the lake with the boys in tow. He observes how beautiful the snow is and then immediately vomits. The boys comfort him and put snow in his mouth. Todd shrieks repeatedly that Neil’s father must have shot him, that Neil would never leave them. The others protest, but Todd escapes from their grasp and runs toward the lake, screaming as he goes. Charlie says to leave him be. The camera zooms out on the snowy lake as Todd walks out onto the dock, appearing miniscule.

Keating sits at his desk in his empty classroom. He goes to Neil’s desk and finds “Five Centuries of Verse” in it. He reads the Thoreau quote written in his own hand on the first page and begins to sob. The voices of Welton boys singing transition to a shot of a service for Neil held in the school’s sanctuary. Headmaster Nolan delivers a mournful tribute to Neil and announces that he’ll conduct a full inquiry into his death at the request of his family.

Neil’s friends gather together in secret, waiting for Cameron, suspecting him of having betrayed them. Charlie says the administration will be looking for a scapegoat. Cameron arrives and admits that he told Nolan everything. The boys hold Charlie back from attacking him. Cameron insists the boys cooperate, believing that they’re victims and that Neil’s suicide is Keating’s fault. Charlie punches him in the face. With a bloody nose, Cameron vehemently maintains that Keating should be fired and that the boys should save themselves.

In the next scene, Nolan walks Meeks back to his room as Todd waits in his. Nolan calls Knox into his office, who gives Todd a thumbs up as he walks by his room. Todd asks Meeks what happened through his door. Meeks says that Charlie was expelled and that he didn’t tell them anything they didn’t already know. Nolan calls for Todd to come in next. His parents are waiting in his office. Nolan asks if Todd was a part of the Dead Poets Society, and Todd admits he was. Nolan reviews the details of the Society’s meetings, and says that Mr. Keating’s abuse of influence as a teacher is what led to Neil’s death. He hands Todd a piece of paper summarizing this and asks Todd to sign it as confirmation that it’s true. The signatures of his friends are already on it. Todd asks what’ll happen to Mr. Keating, but his father insists he sign it.

Mr. McAllister walks with students in the snowy courtyard, reciting verse to them. He sees Mr. Keating in a window and gives a quick wave. Mr. Keating returns the wave from his office full of suitcases. Next, the boys stand beside their desks as Nolan comes in to Keating’s old classroom, acting as the English teacher until Mr. Keating can be replaced. He asks the students where they left off in the textbook. Cameron says that they skipped around a lot, so Nolan decides to start from the beginning. Mr. Keating knocks and enters to retrieve his personals. Nolan asks Cameron to read from the book’s introduction, but Cameron admits that they all ripped it out. Nolan hands him his own copy to read. Todd makes eye contact with Mr. Keating from his office. As Keating leaves the classroom, Todd stands and yells to him that the boys were forced to confess. Keating says he believes him. Nolan silences Todd and demands that Keating leave. As Keating makes for the door, Todd stands on his desk and yells “O captain, my captain!” Nolan tells him to sit, but he doesn’t. Knox stands as well and repeats the phrase. Pitts follows with the same gesture, as does Meeks, followed by many other boys. Cameron noticeably remains seated. Mr. Nolan screams for them all to sit down, but they ignore him. The boys stare at Mr. Keating, who thanks them earnestly and leaves the room. The film ends on a shot of Todd’s face, appearing heartbroken but proud.

Analysis

The film’s final scenes take a morbid tone as the various characters cope with Neil’s suicide. Todd demonstrates complete denial, even accusing Neil’s father of being the one who killed his son. This statement, while not literally accurate, holds some weight, as it was the trapped position that Neil’s father put him in that drove him to end his life. One could argue that, in this way, his father did figuratively kill him. Meanwhile, Keating sobs openly, deeply distraught at the loss of his student. Displaying the warm and carefree Keating in this heartbroken light casts an immovable shadow over the entire rest of the movie.

Neil’s death allows Welton to rear its ugly head in full: the institution’s brutal conformism only increases as the administration promises to conduct a full inquiry into what happened to Neil. Of course, having already had difficult with Keating, it's perhaps unsurprising that they would use him as a scapegoat for what happened. After all, they believe their strict practices to be what’s best for the students, despite the fact that Neil would’ve cited those very practices as a key component in his decision to end his life. Keating’s contrasting ideologies are therefore the odd piece out in the equation, and the obvious branch to prune to ensure that things return to normal at Welton.

Cameron’s willingness to give Keating up when the boys meet in secret demonstrates the powerful, lasting influence of the academy’s ideologies. While Keating managed to inspire and encourage many of the Dead Poets Society members into believing in his ideas about independence and non-conformity, Cameron represents the other side of the equation: those who still believe that Welton is in the right and that Mr. Keating’s teachings were rightfully to blame for Neil’s death. He is concrete proof that Keating's impact was not so easily made on everyone.

The administration's decision to pressure the implicated members of the Dead Poets Society into signing a paper blaming Mr. Keating's influence for Neil's death is an unfortunate parallel to the hold that Neil's parents had over him: straight to the end, much of the movie's misfortune comes from forcing the hand of adolescent boys who either aren't mature enough to make these difficult decisions themselves or who are not of legal age to act independently without threat of serious backlash from their parents and superiors. This is exemplified particularly when Todd tries to ask questions and put off signing the paper until his father interjects and forces him to sign it. The film's themes of discipline and tradition are driven home, with the administration's old-school ideologies appearing to win out, at least for the moment.

The famous final scene in which members of Keating’s class stand and salute him with the declaration “O Captain! My Captain!” is a stirring testament to the impact that Keating will leave on his students after he’s gone. That they are defiant enough to carry out this gesture in plain viewing of Mr. Nolan, and despite his protests, speaks immediately to the rebellious influence Keating had on them. The use of the phrase, “O Captain! My Captain!” is also a reference to Walt Whitman mourning the loss of President Abraham Lincoln, whom Whitman admired very much, following his assassination. In a direct parallel, the boys mourn the loss of a great teacher taken from them under circumstances that they consider unjust, in a moving gesture that has become cinematically iconic over the years.

Analysis Of The Controversial Scene Of Neil's Death In The Movie "The Dead Poets Society"

Neil's (played by Robert Shaun Leonard) demise was in absolutely no possible way a random occurrence in the movie "Dead Poets Society" or in short DPA. Neil's death can in fact be compared to a conclusion in a science experiment that was already clearly stated in the hypothesis. A very high quantity of events and symbolism was used in the early structural stages of the movie to give the viewer an obvious impression that he would live to see out the completion of the movie.

The scene of Neil's death instigates as soon as the school play that Neil was taking part had concluded and Neil was ushered out of the building by his father (Kurtwood Smith) and into their car. Neil, in his father's point of view is displaying his arrogance by disobeying his father by taking part I the school play when he was "instructed" not to. But in Neil's point of view he is fulfilling his own ambitions of becoming an actor and what he truly enjoys. When they arrived home, father and son had a discussion about Neil's future in other words the father dictated Neil's on what he is going to do with his future, the reason being that they were not a wealthy family. Neil's father wanted him to attend a very prestigious university known as Harvard, but Neil had other ideas. He wanted to further explore the world of acting and chose a career path of an actor. Mr. Perry would not yield to Neil's protests that that choice was his to make, but eventually fell silent in defeat. In this section, the camera alternatively changes from Neil to his father as they argue, and most of the time, close up shots are used.

There is a very high probability that this confrontation with his father will have had a subsequent effect on Neil's decision to commit suicide. After this event Neil makes way to his room and after undressing prepares to sleep, but little did his father know that after he had slept his son was still wide awake deep in thought. His clothes are placed in his bed, neatly folded. This gives him the appearance of a military member, everything clean and ordered, suggesting that Neil life is not under his own control but under the control of his parents because they are the ones who are making all the major decisions in his life for him. In other words the parents prevent him from being a free thinker like Mr. Keating encourages him to be. At this point in the movie, an eerie vibrant music had initiated. The music contained a holy tune like that in a church and sounded very much like bees humming. This music gave the viewer the impression that a very important event in the movie was about to take place in the Perry residence that night.

Neil gets up when Mr. and Mrs. Perry are asleep. Other than the...

Loading: Checking Spelling

0%

Read more

Dead Poets Society - The Message of the Dead Poets

763 words - 3 pages Dead Poets Society - The Message of the Dead Poets   Teachers are wonderful heroes. In the movie, Dead Poets Society the teacher/hero is John Keating, played magnificently by Robin Williams. The film takes place at a small preparatory boys' school (Welton Academy) in the late 1950's. The story follows the lives of a group of students and the way that Mr. Keating's teachings influence them. He encourages the boys to become freethinkers...

The Marrow Of Life: Transcendentalism in the Dead Poets Society

1282 words - 5 pages Tom Schulman’s Dead Poets Society serves as a fictitious but accurate account of the Transcendentalist experiment in which a group of boys—led and encouraged by their English teacher Mr. Keating—liberate themselves from the order and tradition of Welton Academy in order to discover their own selves and wills. These teachings of free thought, individualism, and nonconformity, replete with platitudinous or otherwise vague and meaningless language,...

The Beliefs of Transceldentalism in Dead Poets Society

677 words - 3 pages The Beliefs of Transceldentalism in Dead Poests SocietyTranscendentalism emerged as a philosophical and literary movement during the nineteenth century which focused on intuition and the individual conscience. Transcendentalism gained support from writers such as Emerson Thoreau. These supporters believed that fundamental truths are known to the heart and therefore cannot be grasped by the senses. As applied to modern times, the movie...

The communication aspects of the "Dead Poets Society"

2411 words - 10 pages "The Dead Poets Society" is an awe inspiring film set in the 1950s about a teacher who went against the grain and taught his high school students to think for themselves and not allow their attitudes and behavior to be constrained by conformity by older generations. In our class lectures/discussions, we have touched on many aspects of human culture and communication and this movie illustrates many of these concepts. Perspectives, gender,...

Dead Poets Society: The Influence Of Transcendental Thinking

743 words - 3 pages Dead Poets Society: The Influence of Transcendental Thinking Transcendental thinking has an extremely empowering and influential effect upon whoever listens to its teachings. Transcendental thinkers such as Ralph Waldo Emerson and Henry David Thoreau greatly influence three main characters from Dead Poets Society. The movie Dead...

The Importance of Individuality in the Film "The Dead Poets Society"

734 words - 3 pages “Boys, you must strive to find your own voice. Because the longer you wait to begin, the less likely you are to find it at all. Thoreau said, ‘Most men lead lives of quiet desperation.’ Don't be resigned to that. Break out!”—John Keating (Robin Williams) As the above quote says, one should never be resigned to dullness, but instead you should break out and try something new. It is our differences that make us great. However, one cannot expect...

Analysis of the Closet Scene in Hamlet the Movie

821 words - 3 pages Hamlet is often seen as one of the most well known examples of an Oedipus Complex presented in literature. The reasons for this is probably because of the plot that resolves around the revenge that Hamlet has against his step-father Claudius and because of the relationship that Hamlet has with his mother that is loaded with sexual energy. Hamlet's love for his mother is especially exemplified by the Mel Gibson's interpretation of the infamous...

The Theme of Death in "The Dead"

2375 words - 10 pages Although a scene of a funeral home might come to mind when a reader first hears a short story aptly named “The Dead,” the tale actually takes place in the festive setting of a winter dance at the home of the two aunts of the main character, Gabriel Conroy. James Joyce’s short story “The Dead” has a literal title, because its main concept is death – both physical death and spiritual death. Gabriel Conroy and his wife, Gretta Conroy, attend a...

How does the director, Pete Weir, shape our response to the issue of conformity versus individualism in the film Dead Poets Society?

829 words - 3 pages 370791XStage 1: EnglishHow does the director, Pete Weir, shape our response to the issue of conformity versus individualism in the film Dead Poets Society? Respond to the question in an essay.In the film Dead Poets Society there are two main issues that are focused upon. These two issues include the battle between whether conformity or individualism is right. We are shown...

Critique of Keating's Teaching Methods in Dead Poets Society

602 words - 2 pages In the movie, Dead Poets Society, the basic idea of expression is being taught by Keating. Keating is a very unique instructor who uses many different methods of teaching to get the students involved, but he shows them ways to have fun also. That in itself is very unique. Keating is trying to release the emotions these students have within themselves. He is teaching them to...

The controversial issue of death penalty

1284 words - 5 pages THE DEATH PENALTY"THE DEATH SENTENCE IS THE MOST CONTROVERSIAL ISSUE ACROSS OUR WORLD"the death penalty is a very common controversial socialissue across our world.every time a death penalty case arises, and time comesfor the convict, thousands of people across the countries support the punishment as well as protest the...

0 Replies to “Dead Poets Society Scene Analysis Essays”

Lascia un Commento

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *